Judge to VW: Find a fix quick for dirty diesel cars

WASHINGTON – A federal judge overseeing hundreds of class-action lawsuits against Volkswagen says he wants a firm answer within a month about how the German automaker plans to bring nearly 600,000 diesel cars into compliance with clean air laws.

U.S. District Court Judge Charles R. Breyer told Volkswagen’s lawyers at a hearing in California on Thursday that he expects them to report back by March 24. By then, the judge wants to know from the company about available technical solutions to fix the cars and the status of negotiations on a potential settlement with affected owners.

Volkswagen admitted to U.S. regulators in September it had used illegal software installed in its so-called “Clean Diesel” engines. The cheating allowed cars to pass laboratory emissions tests while spewing levels of harmful nitrogen oxide at up to 40 times the level allowed when operating on real roads.

Breyer said six months is enough time for VW to find a fix. The judge also stressed that every day the vehicles remain on the road excess pollution is going into the atmosphere, and Volkswagen owners are stuck with cars they can’t sell.

“It’s an ongoing harm that has to be addressed,” Breyer said. “I’ve found the process is a function of how much time people have available to fill. The story about lawyers is that that if you give them a year to do something, it will take them a year to do something. If you give them 30 days to do something, they’ll do something in 30 days.”

Volkswagen is currently in settlement negotiations with the phalanx of lawyers representing the owners of the defective cars, as well as the Environmental Protection Agency and the California Air Resources Board. Both state and federal regulators will have to sign off on any planned recall. There is also an ongoing criminal probe into the company’s actions.

Breyer suggested VW shouldn’t necessarily wait for all those issues to be settled to take some sort of action, even if it isn’t in the best interest of shareholders.

The judge also told government lawyers that regulators need to respond to the car maker’s proposals quickly. “I don’t want to hear where we’ve given this to the government and we don’t have a response from the government,” Breyer said.

Volkswagen spokeswoman Jeannine Ginivan said Thursday the company is working to find solutions “as quickly as possible,” but didn’t give a timetable.

VW dealers, who have been unable to sell diesel cars since September, were heartened that the court was moving things along. “Volkswagen needs direction,” said Steve Kalafer, chairman of a dealership in Flemington, New Jersey. “If you look at what has taken place so far, given their own direction, there will be no path to closure.”


Krisher reported from Detroit.


Follow Michael Biesecker on Twitter at and find his work at


This story has been corrected to change the day to Thursday